A baker holds up a loaf of pav freshly baked on the Yazdani Bakery in Mumbai. A authorities plan to ban wood-fired ovens in bakeries as a method to curb air pollution might result in a worth enhance within the beloved pav — and erase its smoky taste.
Indranil Aditya for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Indranil Aditya for NPR
MUMBAI, India — Each morning, when the town of Mumbai sleeps, the workers of Yazdani Bakery get up to knead dough, reduce it into little items and pop it into the oven. By daybreak, they’re prepared with their hottest providing: a thousand items of pav, which flies off the cabinets as quickly because the bakery opens.
Pav is a mushy and fluffy bread, with a crusty prime and a definite smoky taste. It resembles a Parker Home roll besides there is no such thing as a egg within the pav’s dough. The phrase originates from the Portuguese phrase for bread — pao. It arrived in India with Portuguese merchants who sailed into close by harbors greater than 600 years in the past and introduced with them a style of residence.
It grew to become a road meals fixture within the nineteenth century, when the port metropolis was rising as a textile hub, drawing staff from close by cities and villages to its cotton spinning and weaving factories.
“Pav is what Bombay’s working-class blue-collar staff have been consuming, particularly those that have been removed from residence with out the infrastructure to create Indian meals for them,” says Mumbai-based meals anthropologist Kurush dalalreferring to the town by its former title.
A baker in Mumbai weighs dough that may turn into the beloved pav bread.
Indranil Aditya for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Indranil Aditya for NPR
Since then, Mumbai’s inhabitants has grown ten instances over the previous century to 12 million. This teeming port metropolis is residence to Bollywood, inventory markets, billionaire industrialists and hundreds of thousands of migrants, of collars blue and white, residing in slums and skyscrapers. Mumbai’s textile factories as we speak are hulking shells of their previous, overgrown by wild fig timber.
However pav stays a working class staple. A stack of six — known as a lod — prices lower than 25 cents.
A bread’s hazy future
However now, pav’s survival is in peril.
In February , the federal government introduced that it might ban wood-fired bakeries throughout the town within the subsequent six months. The order got here a number of months after the Mumbai-based Bombay Environmental Motion Group printed a examine claiming that over the course of a yr, air pollution from Mumbai’s 1,000-odd wood-fired bakeries was as dangerous to every resident as smoking 400 cigarettes.
However critics say it is a case of misplaced priorities — of choosing on the little man. “The air pollution that’s emitted from these bakeries is nothing in comparison with the air pollution that building websites are contributing or the highway restore websites are contributing,” says former city council consultant Makarand narwekar.
Bakers on the Yazdani Bakery in Mumbai knead trays of dough.
Indranil Aditya for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Indranil Aditya for NPR
He factors to the large makeover being undertaken by Mumbai’s civic physique to remake the town’s roads, which has solely worsened mud and visitors. A examine by the Indian climate-tech group Respirer Residing Sciences discovered Mumbai’s air was unsafe for almost half of 2024.
Ravi Andhale, chief of the air pollution management board, acknowledges that wood-fired bakeries aren’t the worst offenders in Mumbai. In response to the Bombay Environmental Motion Group examine they solely contribute 3% of the town’s particulate matter air pollution – referring to matter within the air smaller than 10 micrometers in diameter). However “simply because your share is little — you shouldn’t do something — will not be acceptable,” he says.
And the lead creator of the examine which spotlighted how polluting wood-fired bakeries are says one motive why they’re being focused is that it is simply simpler to resolve that little slice of the issue.
“So far as the air pollution from building, infrastructure and autos go, they’ve loads of complexities,” says Hema Ramani, an environmental advisor who works on authorized and coverage points. “That is why we mentioned let us take a look at sooner, faster, smaller transitions that may occur. Then you definately transfer on to the larger ones.”
Ramani says she would not need the bakeries to close store, solely change to a cleaner gas like pure fuel or electrical energy. The federal government may also help, she says, by subsidizing the gear or transition prices.
However Nasir Ansari, president of the Bombay Bakers Affiliation, says that might enhance the price of the pav by greater than a half. “Pav is usually the meals of the working-class. Even a small worth rise makes an enormous distinction. A couple of months in the past, we had raised the value of a stack of six by three rupees” — a few pennies. “We nonetheless had clients asking me why I did that.”
A baker locations dough right into a wood-fired range at Yazdani Bakery.
Indranil Aditya for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Indranil Aditya for NPR
Why pav is beloved
It isn’t nearly the price, pav bakers say. The wood-fired bread is a part of Mumbai’s cosmopolitan heritage, a melange of indigenous and colonial traditions.
This Portuguese-origin bread is now eaten with a fried potato snack known as ‘vada,’ a buttery vegetable mash known as ‘bhaji’, or spiced hen or lamb mince known as boil. “They’re additionally nice vessels for mopping up every kind of gravies and curries — and nearly all the things Indian,” says Dalal.
A baker carries loaves of recent bread within the kitchen of Yazdani Bakery.
Indranil Aditya for NPR
cover caption
toggle caption
Indranil Aditya for NPR
Perzon Zend, proprietor of the Yazdani Bakery, says shedding the wood-fired pav would take away one thing intangible from Mumbai’s cosmopolitan heritage. He factors to his circle of relatives historical past: Zend’s ancestors got here from Iran greater than hundred years in the past — and arrange Mumbai’s most iconic Iranian eating places and bakeries — the place their key product is a Portuguese-origin bread. It has been an excellent enterprise for the household. He faucets his potbelly to reveal.
“I positively need clear air in Bombay,” says Zend. “However I do not wish to be the smallest and the simplest goal.”
And he thinks the tactic of baking is the important thing to success. “You possibly can’t beat the wood-fire,” he says. “In America, you smoke the chops and that smokiness is all the things. It is like that with pav too.” These made in electrical ovens, he says, “style like cardboard.”
